Outcome after Mesh or Shouldice Herniorrhaphy

BACKGROUND: Inguinal herniorrhaphy remains one of the most common general surgical operations. Mesh repair is advocated by several specialized hernia centers. The purpose of this study was to compare results of mesh and Shouldice repair for inguinal herniae. METHODS: A clinical review was made of 73 cases of inguinal herniae treated during the 3 years from January 1993 to December 1996 at the Department of Surgery, Dae Rim Saint Mary's Hospital, and at the Department of Surgery, Eum Sung Saint Mary's Hospital. We treated 38 patients with mesh repair and 35 patients with a Shouldice procedure. Among 73 cases, 72 cases were males and only one case was a female. All except 8 cases had indirect types of hernias. RESULTS: Mesh repair required less time (80 minutes) and was an easier operative technique than the Shouldice procedure (95 minutes), but postoperative pain was similar between the two procedures. Postoperative pain was relieved after one week in 60% of the patients and after four weeks in 88% of the patients. The complications following the operations were similar between the two procedures: voiding difficulties developed in two cases, wound infection in one case, and a hematoma in two cases. There were no recurrences during the 6 month to 3 year follow up. CONCLUSIONS: Inguinal herniorrhaphy using a mesh repair technique provides is simple, rapid, less painful, and effective.

A Clinical Analysis of Traumatic Diaphragmatic Rupture

A clinical analysis was made of 18 cases of traumatic diaphragmatic rupture which had been treated during the 8 years from January 1989 to December 1997 at the Department of Surgery & Chest Surgery, Dae Rim Saint Mary's Hospital. The results are as follows: 1) The most common ages were 3rd and 4th decades (61.1%).There were 14 males and 4 females (M : F = 3.5 : 1) 2) The traumatic diaphragmatic ruptures were due to blunt trauma in 13 (72.2%) patients (left 10, right 3) and penetrating trauma in 5 (27.8%) patients (left 5). 3) The common symptoms were dyspnea (77.8%), abdominal pain (66.7%), and chest pain (55.6%). 4) 12 of the 18 patients were diagnosed before operation. Six patients were diagnosed during operation. 5) 15 of the 18 patients were operated on within 24 hours (83.3%). 6) The most common associated intraabdominal injured organ was spleen (44.4%). The most common herniated organ was colon (27.8%). 7) Most of the injuries ranged in size from 6 to 10 cm in the blunt trauma patients (53.8%) and less than 5 cm in penetrating trauma patients (100%). 8) The operations were done using a laparotomy alone in 11 patients, a thoracotomy in 5 patients, and a thoracoabdominal incision in 2 patients. 9) Postoperative complications were developed in 8 patients (44.4%). 10) The perioperative mortality was 11.1%, and the causes of deaths were hypovolemic shock and septic shock. In conculusion, traumatic diaphragmatic rupture without severe associated organ injury could reveal a good outcome, if early diagnosis and proper treatment was performed.

A Comparative Study of the Clinical Features between Negative Appendectomy and Conservative Treatment Groups in Suspected Appendicitis

This study is a clinical review of two groups of patients. Group I was composed of 97 patients who were submitted to negative appendectomy under the impression of acute appendicitis and, group II was 45 patients who received conservative treatment with the same impression at the department of surgery, Dae Rim Saint Mary's Hospital, from January 1, 1994 to August 31, 1996.The purpose of this study is to identify possible factors for the decision of operation or conservative treatment in the patients with suspected appendicitis and so to decrease unnecessary operation. Clinical characteristics of the patients were compared between two groups by the method of comparison of means(X test). The following results were obtained; 1) The incidences of group I and group II among the patients in the state of suspicious appendicitis were 97 of 1,004 cases(9.7%) and 45 of 1,004 cases(4.5%) respectively. 2) The number of female patients was 1.5 times more than male in both groups(p0.05) 8) Leukocytosis above 10,000/mm3 appeared in 44% of patients in group I and 53.3% in group II(p>0.05). 9) In admission route, the patients via ER was 2 times more than those of OPD in group I and in group II that was 5 times more than this.